The English Premier League is the richest soccer league in the world, and in recent years, the EPL has taken its wealth to new levels, with even smaller clubs spending exorbitant fees on players.
Strikers make up a big portion of transfers as teams often are willing to throw huge wads of cash at exciting, sometimes unproven, goal scorers. But no matter the position, it’s important to spend wisely.
Bringing in a player who can’t cut it in the Premier League can be devastating. One bad roster move could cost clubs a chance at trophies or cause them to be relegated to the second division.
These are the worst transfers in Premier League history.
Note: All fees are listed in English pounds (and current U.S. dollars), based on the best available information. Some fees are media estimates or unknown.
47. Nikola Jerkan
Croatia’s Nikola Jerkan, right, challenges Denmark’s Kim Vilfort during a European Soccer Championships match in 1996. Dusan Vranic / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £1 million ($1.27 million)
Team: Nottingham Forest
Years: 1996-97, 1998-99
Position: Defender
Goals: 0
Appearances: 14
Fee (sold): Free
Bottom line: Bought during the heyday of Croatian superstars, Nikola Jerkan proved to be fool’s gold in his one season in the Premier League.
He was a shaky defender, scored zero goals, and picked up five yellow cards in his 14 appearances.
After spending a season on loan, he returned for the 1998-99 season but did not make an appearance before being released.
43. Christian Benteke
Liverpool’s Christian Benteke, center, fights for the ball against West Bromwich Albion in 2015. Jon Super / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £32.5 million ($41.4 million)
Team: Liverpool
Years: 2015-16
Position: Striker
Goals: 10
Appearances: 42
Fee (sold): £27 million ($34.4 million)
Bottom line: Christian Benteke wasn’t awful for Liverpool, and the team sold him for a fairly high fee, but he’s seen as a disappointment in the eyes of Liverpool fans.
The Reds paid a high fee for the player who was prolific at Aston Villa, but he never fit Jurgen Klopp’s style and was sold after only a season on Merseyside.
42. Daniel Amokachi
Daniel Amokachi, in front, with Everton teammates after winning the 1995 FA Cup. Everton Football Club / YouTube
Fee (Bought): £3.15 million ($4.0 million)
Team: Everton
Years: 1994-96
Position: Forward
Goals: 10
Appearances: 43
Fee (sold): £1.8 million ($2.3 million)
Bottom line: Remembered for a great goal for Nigeria against Greece in the 1994 World Cup, Daniel Amokachi didn’t do too much for Everton.
His most famous moment was substituting himself into the FA Cup semifinal game agains Tottenham. He had been told to warm up, but he instead went into the game while another player was receiving treatment. All Amokachi did was score two goals in the game.
Everton went on to win the 1995 FA Cup, so Amokachi did give fans of the Blues fond memories.
35. Alireza Jahanbaksh
Alireza Jahanbaksh training with Iran’s national team in 2019. Hadi Abyar / Wikimedia
Fee (bought): £17 million ($21.6 million)
Team: Brighton and Hove Albion
Years: 2018-Present
Position: Winger, attacking midfielder
Goals: 0
Appearances: 25
Fee (sold): N/A
Bottom line: Brighton is not the first team to be fooled by a player’s impressive stats in the Eredivisie, but it now has joined the list of teams that will cast a cynical view toward the next high-scoring striker in the Dutch League.
The Iranian Alireza Jahanbaksh was the leading scorer in the 2017-18 Eredivisie season, but failed to register a single goal or assist for Brighton.
Injuries played a part, but he still had 25 appearances to make an impression and failed.
29. Alexis Sanchez
Manchester United’s Alexis Sanchez during an English Premier League match against the Wolverhampton Wanderers in 2018. Rui Vieira / AP Photo
Fee (bought): Straight swap for Henrik Mkhitaryan
Team: Manchester United
Years: 2018-present
Position: Forward
Goals: 5
Appearances: 45
Fee (sold): N/A
Bottom line: Alexis Sanchez was a star at Barcelona and a world-class player at Arsenal. He once had a season of 30 goals and 14 assists. That was the player Manchester United thought they were getting when they agreed to pay his exorbitant wages.
Instead, the Chilean has been a peripheral figure, barely contributing anything like his incredible output at Arsenal.
Along the way, Sanchez has made £350,000 ($445,375) a week, the second highest wage in the Premier League.
25. Jô
Portland Timbers defender Stephen Keel, left, works to contain Manchester City forward Jô during an exhibition game in 2010. Don Ryan / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £19 million ($24.7 million)
Team: Manchester City
Years: 2008-09, 2010-11
Position: Striker
Goals: 6
Appearances: 42
Fee (sold): £7.98 million ($10.4 million)
Bottom line: A few months before Manchester City became the team with unlimited cash, it paid a significant amount for Brazilian striker Jô. He was the team’s record signing at the time and failed to live up to the hype.
Fortunately for Man City, this move didn’t hamper the team for long. Soon after, the Mansour group bought the team, and a £19 million fee for a player ($24.7 million today) would be considered peanuts.
24. Bruno Cheyrou
Liverpool’s Bruno Cheyrou, in front, fights for a ball with Levski’s Ilian Stoyanov during a UEFA Cup game in 2004. Dimitar Deinov / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £4.5 million ($5.9 million)
Team: Liverpool
Years: 2002-04
Position: Midfielder
Goals: 5
Appearances: 48
Fee (sold): £800,000 ($1.04 million)
Bottom line: It’s not Bruno Cheyrou’s fault that his new manager at Liverpool hailed him as the “New Zidane.”
In fact, putting him among the worst transfers might be unfair since the fee for him wasn’t exorbitant for a club of Liverpool’s size.
But his contributions to the team were still minimal. Though several of his five goals were scored in big moments, his overall output wasn’t exactly Zidane-like.
19. Eric Djemba-Djemba
Lyon’s Pierre Alain Frau, left, dribbles Manchester’s Eric Djemba Djemba, right, works against Lyon in a UEFA Champions League soccer match in 2004. Patrick Gardin / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £3.5 million ($4.6 million)
Team: Manchester United
Years:
Position: Midfielder
Goals: 2
Appearances: 39
Fee (sold): £2.5 million ($3.3 million)
Bottom line: Brought in to replace the legendary Roy Keane, Eric Djemba-Djemba had all the aggressiveness of Keane but lacked everything else.
Djemba-Djemba made a name for himself with his hard and dangerous tackling. Premier League opponents were glad to see him leave the league in 2008 after stays at Aston Villa and Burnley.
16. Mario Balotelli
Liverpool’s Mario Balotelli, center, fights for the ball against Chelsea during an English Premier League soccer match in 2014. Jon Super / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £16 million ($20.8 million)
Team: Liverpool
Years: 2014-15
Position: Striker
Goals: 4
Appearances: 28
Fee (sold): Free
Bottom line: The definition of a desperation purchase, the enigmatic striker arrived on Merseyside with plenty of baggage from his time at Manchester City.
The difference between his tenures with the Sky Blues and the Reds? Goals.
He scored for fun at City, and scored almost none with Liverpool, before being sent on loan and eventually allowed to leave for free.
14. Ricky Van Wolfswinkel
Ricky Van Wolfswinkel made 28 appearances for Norwich City. matrix-frames-autograph-store / ebay
Fee (bought): £8 million ($10.4 million)
Team: Norwich City
Years: 2013-14, 2015-16
Position: Striker
Goals: 2
Appearances: 28
Fee (sold): £500,000 ($650,178)
Bottom line: Ricky Van Wolfswinkel was a solid player who was not suited for the physicality of the Premier League.
Van Wolfswinkel came to Norwich with a great goal-scoring reputation, but he completely failed to deliver on that promise, often looking too frail to compete in the rough-and-tumble English top flight.
After a few years in the wilderness, Van Wolfswinkel found his level in the Dutch and Swiss leagues, where he’s a prolific scorer once again.
12. Kostas Mitroglou
Kostas Mitroglou, center, playing for Benfica against Sporting during a Portuguese league soccer match in 2016. Steven Governo / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £12 million ($15.6 million)
Team: Fulham
Years: 2014
Position: Striker
Goals: 0
Appearances: 3
Fee (sold): £6 million ($7.8 million)
Bottom line: A consistent scorer in Greece before arriving at Fulham, Kostas Mitroglou was worthless for the team that was fighting to stay in the Premier League.
Mitroglou should be used as an example of the risks involved in late-January transfers. He was the team’s record signing at the time, yet only made three appearances before being loaned out.
He regained his goal-scoring form in Greece and has had success in Portugal and France since.
10. Juan Sebastian Veron
Manchester United’s Juan Sebastian Veron, right, challenges Bayern Munich’s Stephan Effenberg during a UEFA Champions League soccer match in 2002. Paul Barker / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £24.3 million ($31.6 million)
Team: Manchester United
Years: 2001-03
Position: Midfielder
Goals: 11
Appearances: 82
Fee (sold): £15 million ($19.5 million)
Bottom line: At one point, Juan Sebastian Veron was the most expensive player in the history of the sport, having been sold for a combined £77 million ($100.1 million today).
However, his time with Manchester United, which bought him for an English record £24.3 million ($31.6 million), was considered a major flop.
He often struggled to keep pace in the much quicker Premier League. Despite this, Chelsea was willing to pay £15 million ($19.5 million) to take him off Man U’s hands.
9. Fernando Torres
Chelsea’s Fernando Torres, left, competes for the ball against Manchester United during a Champions League soccer match in 2011. Tom Hevezi / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £50 million ($65 million)
Team: Chelsea
Years: 2010-15
Position: Striker
Goals: 45
Appearances: 172
Fee (sold): Free
Bottom line: “El Niño” was an absolute legend for Liverpool, so it was a shock when he demanded a transfer to Chelsea.
Fernando Torres became the largest transfer in Premier League history at the time, and his tenure wouldn’t be considered a failure if it wasn’t for the colossal figure Chelsea paid for his services.
He contributed to some great moments for the team, but failed to live up to his standards that had been set at Liverpool.
8. Andy Carroll
Liverpool’s Andy Carroll, right, celebrates after scoring a goal against Everton during an English Premier League soccer match in 2011. Tim Hales / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £35 million ($45.5 million)
Team: Liverpool
Years: 2010-14
Position: Striker
Goals: 11
Appearances: 58
Fee (sold): £15 million ($19.5 million)
Bottom line: The reverberation from the shock transfer of Fernando Torres to Chelsea was the insane fee Liverpool paid to Newcastle for the young and exciting Andy Carroll.
Liverpool, desperate and flush with cash, needed to make a splash to counteract the loss of Torres.
Carroll was often injured and, when he wasn’t, did not contribute enough goals to make up for his hefty price tag.
5. Bebé
Manchester United’s Bebé celebrates after scoring a goal against Bursaspor during a Champions League soccer match in 2010. Ibrahim Usta / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £7.4 million ($9.6 million)
Team: Manchester United
Years: 2010-11
Position: Midfielder
Goals: 0
Appearances: 2
Fee (sold): £2.4 million ($3.1 million)
Bottom line: One of the strangest transfers in history. Manchester United brought in the completely unknown Bebé for an average sum at the time, but when Sir Alex Ferguson admitted to having never seen Bebé play, it became apparent that something was afoot.
He only appeared twice for Man U and was loaned out several times.
Somehow, Man U recouped some of its money when the club sold him several years later.
4. Adrian Mutu
Chelsea’s Adrian Mutu, center, is fouled against Sparta Prague during a Champions League soccer match in 2003. Michal Kamaryt,CTK / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £15.8 million ($20.5 million)
Team: Chelsea
Years: 2003-05
Position: Attacking midfielder/forward
Goals: 10
Appearances: 38
Fee (sold): Free
Bottom line: Adrian Mutu’s issue wasn’t that he was a bad player — he scored 10 goals in his first season.
His problems were off the field, where he was banned from the sport for seven months after testing positive for cocaine.
For the next decade, Mutu was embroiled in a legal battle with Chelsea over a breach of contract issue.
3. Angel Di Maria
Manchester United’s Angel Di Maria in an English Premier League game against Queens Park Rangers in 2014. Jon Super / AP Photo
Fee (bought): £59.7 million ($77.6 million)
Team: Manchester United
Years: 2014-15
Position: Winger/attacking midfielder
Goals: 4
Appearances: 32
Fee (sold): £44 million ($57.2 million)
Bottom line: Angel Di Maria has proven through spectacular goals and performances with Real Madrid, Paris St. Germain, and the Argentine national team that he is capable of being a brilliant player.
But his one season with Manchester United was an absolute nightmare. Bought for an exorbitant fee, he failed to live up to the hype and was sold to PSG.
On his return to Manchester in the Champions League with PSG, he took the opportunity to go after the Man U fans after assisting a goal.