What if Bo Jackson Had Never Gotten Injured? The Greatest Athlete Who Never Was
There’s a good reason why this question can still hijack a sports conversation. Vincent “Bo” Jackson goes down in professional sports history as the only athlete ever named an All-Star in both Major League Baseball and the National Football League.
Jackson was a legitimate force on the diamond. He hit towering home runs and turned warning-track catches into optical illusions. On the field, he averaged 5.4 yards per carry, plowing through defenders with speed. His career was proof that a person could excel at two of the toughest pro sports on Earth.
That reality is what gives weight to the events of January 13, 1991. A tackle in a playoff game against Cincinnati dislocated Jackson’s hip, ended his football career, and reshaped his baseball one. The game stopped one of the most unprecedented athletic trajectories in modern history.
So the question is: What if Bo Jackson had stayed healthy? It remains one of sports’ most haunting hypotheticals.
The Making of Bo
Image via Canva/Zac Bargman’s Images
Vincent Edward Jackson grew up in Bessemer, Alabama, and was one of ten children in a house where discipline came from necessity and not much else. He was raw energy in motion, too strong and too fast for his surroundings. By high school, that energy turned into dominance across three sports—football, baseball, and track.
He won state decathlon titles, hit home runs that defied belief, and averaged more than ten yards a carry on the football field. The New York Yankees noticed and drafted him in 1982, but Bo chose Auburn University instead.
At Auburn, he became the definition of a natural. In four seasons, he rushed for more than 4,300 yards and 43 touchdowns, setting SEC records that stood for years. In 1985, he won the Heisman Trophy after rushing for nearly 1,800 yards. He also hit .401 that spring for the Auburn baseball team. There wasn’t a season when he wasn’t the fastest, strongest, or most impossible player on the field.
The Choice That Defined Everything
In 1986, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers made him the first overall pick in the NFL Draft. A dispute with the team cost him his college baseball eligibility, and he swore he’d never play for them. True to his word, he signed with the Kansas City Royals instead, thus trading the NFL spotlight for the grind of the minor leagues.
That same year, he debuted in MLB and recorded his first hit against Hall of Famer Steve Carlton. A year later, the Los Angeles Raiders drafted him in the seventh round, gambling that Bo’s passion for football would pull him back. Raiders owner Al Davis promised he could play both sports, and Bo agreed.
Suddenly, the impossible was real—one man splitting seasons between the NFL and MLB and excelling in both.
Bo Knows Everything
Image via Getty Images/Dmytro Aksonov
Between 1987 and 1990, Bo played outfield for the Kansas City Royals and running back for the Los Angeles Raiders at the same time. In baseball, he hit home runs, including one in his first All-Star Game that traveled 448 feet. In football, he ran over Brian Bosworth on national television and sprinted untouched into the stadium tunnel after a 91-yard touchdown.
Then came the tackle against the Cincinnati Bengals. His hip popped out of its socket, which damaged his blood vessels and led to avascular necrosis. The injury ended his football career and left his baseball one in pieces.
He came back in 1993 after hip replacement surgery and hit a home run in his first at-bat for the Chicago White Sox. It was a promise he had made to his late mother, and it became the last miracle in a career that had already produced more than anyone could have reasonably expected.
The Legacy That Refuses to Fade
If Bo Jackson had stayed healthy, he likely would have extended one of the most remarkable dual-sport careers in history. Based on his production through four NFL seasons, projections put him on pace for roughly 8,000 rushing yards and 45 touchdowns, along with a decade of strong baseball numbers potentially nearing 300 home runs. Even without Hall of Fame totals in either sport, sustained success in both would have set him apart as the most complete athlete of his era.
Yet by his own admission, Jackson had already planned to retire from football before the injury. In that sense, the “what if” is smaller than fans imagine: his body may have failed him, but he was ready to walk away from the gridiron regardless. The real loss was seeing how long Bo Jackson could keep redefining the limits of athletic possibility.