8 Early-Round Draft Choices That Could Make or Break Your Season
Everyone talks up late-round sleepers, but early-round picks are where the tone of the season is set. These involve high draft capital, high expectations, and little room for error. In 2025, a few big names come with just enough uncertainty to change everything, for better or worse.
Jonathan Taylor
Credit: Instagram
A key piece in Indianapolis’s offense, Jonathan Taylor racked up 1,431 rushing yards and 11 touchdowns in 2024. His 303 carries ranked fifth league-wide, and his 4.7 yards per attempt reflect both volume and efficiency. He’s once again a high-floor fantasy back worth building around early.
Tyreek Hill
Credit: Instagram
Speed remains the most terrifying weapon in fantasy, and Tyreek Hill still has it. His 2024 totals—81 receptions, 959 yards, and six touchdowns—were modest by his standards. Still, his ability to flip a game in one play makes him impossible to ignore in early PPR formats.
Patrick Mahomes
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
No matter the weapons around him, Patrick Mahomes finds ways to produce. He closed 2024 with 3,928 passing yards and 26 touchdowns, both top-10 marks. While not his flashiest year, Mahomes’ elite baseline makes him one of the safest early-round quarterback options on the board.
Garrett Wilson
Credit: Instagram
Despite erratic quarterback play, Garrett Wilson hauled in 101 receptions for 1,104 yards and seven touchdowns in 2024. He’s also established his WR1 upside. If the Jets stabilize under center, Wilson could take another step forward in both real-life and fantasy value.
Marvin Harrison Jr.
Credit: Instagram
Rookie seasons this polished don’t come often. Marvin Harrison Jr. posted 62 catches for 885 yards and eight touchdowns, immediately stepping into a featured role in Arizona. He averaged over 14 yards per reception and showed elite ball skills—rare traits that already have him trending toward fantasy stardom.
Breece Hall
Credit: Instagram
The Jets leaned heavily on Breece Hall’s all-around game in 2024. He delivered 876 rushing yards, five rushing touchdowns, plus 483 receiving yards and three more scores. With 57 receptions, Hall remains one of the few backs in the league with true three-down, league-winning potential in any scoring format.
Amon-Ra St. Brown
Credit: Instagram
Consistency defined Amon-Ra St. Brown’s 2024 campaign. He caught 115 passes for 1,263 yards and 12 touchdowns while earning All-Pro honors along the way. His role in Detroit’s offense only continues to grow, and his dependability makes him a premier WR1 in both standard and PPR fantasy leagues.
Christian McCaffrey
Credit: Facebook
A truncated season didn’t fully showcase Christian McCaffrey’s usual dominance. He was limited to four games in 2024 but posted over 300 scrimmage yards and three scores. McCaffrey remains one of fantasy’s most potent dual-threat backs—worth early-round investment for those willing to gamble on upside.
Davante Adams
Credit: X
Las Vegas’ instability didn’t stop Davante Adams from doing what he does best: producing. He ended 2024 with 85 receptions, 1,063 yards, and eight touchdowns. While his peak years may be behind him, Adams continues to be a steady WR1 option, especially in red-zone-heavy formats.
Ja’Marr Chase
Credit: Facebook
Dominant is the only way to describe Ja’Marr Chase’s 2024 campaign. He led the league in receptions (127), yards (1,708), and touchdowns (17), completing the rare receiving triple crown. With Joe Burrow healthy, Chase is arguably the most matchup-proof wideout available in early rounds.
Justin Jefferson
Credit: Facebook
A midseason hamstring injury didn’t derail Justin Jefferson’s status as one of fantasy’s elite receivers. In just 13 games, he totaled 1,533 yards and 10 touchdowns. His elite route running, contested catch ability, and target share guarantee top-tier fantasy returns when he’s on the field.
Rashee Rice
Credit: Instagram
A small sample size in 2024 gave a glimpse of what could come. Rashee Rice recorded 288 yards and two touchdowns in four games before injury and off-field issues derailed his season. If cleared to play full-time, his upside in Kansas City’s offense remains hard to ignore.
Chris Olave
Credit: Instagram
Injuries limited Chris Olave to eight games last season, but he still managed 400 yards and a touchdown on 32 catches. Under normal circumstances, he’s a target magnet with WR1 upside. A full season of stability at quarterback could launch him into weekly starter status across all formats.
Omarion Hampton
Credit: Instagram
College production often hints at pro potential, and Omarion Hampton showed plenty at North Carolina. He rushed for 1,660 yards and 15 touchdowns in 2024. He’s set to debut in Los Angeles and profiles as a rookie candidate with top-20 fantasy upside if he seizes a lead role early.
Kenneth Walker III
Credit: Instagram
There was upside—and inconsistency—for Kenneth Walker III in 2024. He totaled 573 rushing yards, seven touchdowns, and chipped in 299 receiving yards over 11 games. Health was a factor, but when active, his red-zone usage suggests high-end RB2 value with RB1 upside if volume increases.