We Ranked the Top 15 Quarterbacks in NFL History (And You Probably Won’t Like It)
There’s no position in sports quite like quarterback. The pressure, the spotlight, and the legacy all fall on one set of shoulders. These quarterbacks make history with their stats and their postseason magic, and a few have somehow managed both. Here are 15 quarterbacks who left a permanent mark on the NFL.
Tom Brady
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
No one has more wins, yards, or Super Bowl rings. Brady finished with 89,214 passing yards, 649 touchdowns, and seven championships—more than any NFL franchise. He played into his mid-40s and redefined longevity at the position.
Steve Young
Credit: Alchetron
Long before today’s dual-threat QBs became common, Young was slicing defenses with his legs and torching secondaries through the air. His 96.8 career passer rating still ranks among the best. In 1994, he threw six touchdowns in the Super Bowl and took MVP honors.
Peyton Manning
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Manning was a pre-snap tactician who made every play feel like a chess move. He threw for 71,940 yards, 539 touchdowns, and won Super Bowls with the Colts and Broncos. That 2013 season had 55 touchdowns and nearly 5,500 yards, all after a neck surgery that could’ve ended his career.
Joe Montana
Credit: ebay
Montana’s reputation came from precision and calm in high-pressure situations. With four Super Bowl wins and three Super Bowl MVPs, he mastered late-game execution. His 92-yard drive in Super Bowl XXIII remains a benchmark for clutch quarterbacking in an era where defenses dictated the pace.
Patrick Mahomes
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Mahomes has accomplished in under a decade what some Hall of Famers couldn’t in twenty years. Three Super Bowl wins, two MVPs, and a playoff passer rating higher than any quarterback ever. His off-balance throws and improvisation challenge defensive logic. Still under 30, he’s already forced a redefinition of what elite quarterback play looks like.
Drew Brees
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
At just six feet tall, Brees was told he didn’t have the size. He responded with more than 80,000 passing yards and a Super Bowl MVP. After the Chargers moved on from him, he helped revitalize the Saints and New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina.
Johnny Unitas
Credit: Wikipedia
Unitas helped transition football from the ground game to the air. His streak of 47 games with a touchdown pass lasted over 50 years. He won four championships—three in the NFL and one Super Bowl—and set the tone for quarterback play in the late ’50s and ’60s.
Aaron Rodgers
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Rodgers made throwing deep look casual. He won four MVPs and owns the highest single-season passer rating at 122.5. He became known for his improvisational ability and pre-snap manipulation.
Dan Marino
Credit: ebay
Marino never won a Super Bowl, but he didn’t need rings to leave a legacy. His 1984 season—5,084 yards and 48 touchdowns—was a blueprint for the modern passing game. He retired holding the major passing records and changed expectations about how fast and far the ball could be thrown.
John Elway
Credit: ebay
Elway played in five Super Bowls, winning his final two, and retired with over 51,000 passing yards and 33 rushing touchdowns. His athleticism and toughness defined Denver football for nearly two decades.
Roger Staubach
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Staubach arrived late after his Navy commitment but didn’t waste time making an impact. He won two Super Bowls with Dallas and became the original face of the Cowboys brand. He is known for his late-game comebacks and thoughtful decision-making, and finished with an 85-29 regular-season record, one of the best winning percentages ever.
Fran Tarkenton
Credit: ebay
Before running quarterbacks were normal, Tarkenton scrambled like his life depended on it. He rushed for over 3,600 yards and threw for more than 47,000. He led the Vikings to three Super Bowl appearances and retired holding several major passing records. Opposing linemen hated chasing him, while fans loved watching him extend plays.
Brett Favre
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Favre started 297 consecutive games (321 if you count playoffs), a record that may never fall. He won three straight MVPs and finished with 508 passing touchdowns and over 71,000 yards. Mistakes were part of the package, but so was the magic.
Ben Roethlisberger
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Big Ben was never flashy, but he was brutally effective. At 6’5″, he led the Steelers to two Super Bowl wins and threw for over 64,000 yards. Roethlisberger recorded 53 game-winning drives, more than Montana, Marino, and Brees. His toughness became a Pittsburgh trademark.
Troy Aikman
Credit: Youtube
Aikman won three Super Bowls in four years and delivered when it mattered most. His numbers weren’t flashy, but he was efficient and reliable in big moments. He earned six Pro Bowl selections and threw four touchdowns in Super Bowl XXVII. On a balanced team, he provided the steady hand behind a dynasty.